top of page

Wood Burning vs Gas Fires: Which Is Best for Your Home?

May 16, 2016
8 min read

Updated: Oct 23


A wood burner in a cosy traditional lounge

Choosing a new fireplace is about more than simply adding warmth to a room. The right fire can transform your living space, create a welcoming atmosphere and become a beautiful focal point in your home.

But when it comes to wood-burning stoves versus gas fires, which is the better choice?

Both options have their advantages. Wood-burning stoves offer the traditional experience of a real log fire, complete with the sights, sounds and aromas of burning wood. Gas fires, on the other hand, provide instant warmth, convenient controls and a choice of contemporary and traditional designs.

The best option depends on your home, your lifestyle, your budget and what you want from your fireplace.

At Sussex Eco Solutions, we help homeowners explore different fires and fireplaces to find a solution that suits their property and heating requirements. In this guide, we'll compare wood-burning and gas fires to help you make an informed decision.

Wood Burning vs Gas Fires: What's the Difference?

Although both can create a warm and inviting living space, wood-burning stoves and gas fires work in different ways.

A wood-burning stove generates heat by burning logs inside a combustion chamber. It creates a traditional flame and requires a suitable flue or chimney arrangement, along with regular fuel supplies and maintenance.

A gas fire burns natural gas or LPG, depending on the appliance and installation. Many modern models offer convenient controls, adjustable heat settings and realistic flame effects without the need to handle logs or remove wood ash.

Neither option is automatically the best for every home. Understanding their differences will help you decide which is right for you.

1. Wood-Burning Stoves: Traditional Charm and Real Flames

For many homeowners, nothing compares with the atmosphere of a real log fire.

Wood-burning stoves bring character and warmth to a room, whether you're updating a traditional cottage, renovating a period property or creating a cosy feature in a contemporary living space.

The advantages of wood-burning stoves

The authentic experience

A real wood fire offers natural flames, glowing embers and the familiar crackle of burning logs. If atmosphere is just as important to you as heat, a wood-burning stove can be an appealing choice.

A distinctive focal point

Wood burners are available in a wide range of designs, from classic cast-iron stoves to sleek, contemporary models with large glass viewing windows. The right stove can complement your interior and make a fireplace the centrepiece of the room.

Control over your fuel supply

You can purchase seasoned logs from a supplier or, where appropriate, source your own wood. However, wood must be properly seasoned or certified as Ready to Burn where the relevant rules apply. Wet or unsuitable wood can increase smoke, reduce performance and contribute to deposits in the flue.

Effective radiant heat

Wood-burning stoves can provide substantial radiant heat, making them particularly appealing for homeowners who enjoy a warm living room during colder weather. How much of your home they heat depends on the stove's output, the layout of your property, insulation and the way heat moves between rooms.

What should you consider before choosing a wood burner?

A wood-burning stove needs more involvement than a gas fire.

You'll need somewhere suitable to store your logs, and you'll need to clean the stove and arrange regular chimney sweeping and maintenance. Installation requirements also need to be assessed, including the flue, ventilation, hearth and clearances from combustible materials.

You should also check whether your property is in a smoke control area. In England, wood can only be burned in an appropriate exempt appliance in these areas, subject to the applicable rules and the manufacturer's instructions.

For homeowners who enjoy the traditional experience and don't mind the extra upkeep, a wood burner can be a rewarding addition to the home.

2. Gas Fires: Convenience and Contemporary Design

If you love the appearance of a flame but prefer a more convenient heating option, a gas fire could be the right choice. Modern gas fires have developed considerably over the years. There are models to suit traditional fireplaces as well as contemporary interiors, with options including glass-fronted designs, realistic fuel beds and sophisticated flame effects.

The advantages of gas fires

Convenient heating

Many gas fires can be switched on at the touch of a button, allowing you to enjoy warmth without carrying logs, lighting a fire or waiting for it to establish itself.

Easy-to-use controls

Depending on the model, you may have access to a remote control, adjustable heat settings, a thermostat or other convenient control features.

Less day-to-day cleaning

Gas fires don't produce wood ash or require log storage. They still need appropriate servicing and maintenance, but the everyday cleaning routine is generally simpler than that of a wood-burning stove.

A choice of styles

Gas fires are available in a variety of designs, including inset fires, hole-in-the-wall models and more traditional fireplace styles. Some offer striking flame effects that work beautifully in modern living spaces.

What should you consider before choosing a gas fire?

A gas fire requires a suitable gas supply and an installation that meets the appliance manufacturer's requirements and relevant regulations. Depending on the model and your property, you may need an appropriate chimney, flue or balanced flue arrangement.

You should also consider the availability and future cost of gas, as well as the appliance's efficiency and the amount of heat it delivers to your room.

Gas appliances must be installed and serviced by appropriately qualified Gas Safe registered professionals.

If you want a fireplace that combines attractive flames with straightforward everyday use, a gas fire is well worth considering.

3. Which Is Cheaper to Run: Wood or Gas?

Running costs are an important consideration when choosing a new fire, but there isn't one answer that applies to every household.

The cost of heating your home depends on several factors, including fuel prices, the efficiency of your appliance, how often you use it and how much useful heat you need.

Wood-burning stove running costs

Your running costs will depend on the price of your logs, the amount you burn and the efficiency of your stove.

If you can obtain suitable, properly dried wood at a competitive price, a wood burner may offer attractive running costs. However, you should also account for fuel delivery, storage, chimney sweeping and routine maintenance.

Gas fire running costs

Gas fire running costs depend on the price you pay for gas, the appliance's efficiency and the amount of heat you use.

A modern, efficient gas fire may provide convenient heat with relatively little day-to-day effort. However, the cost of running it will vary with energy tariffs and how you operate the appliance.

How can you compare the two fairly?

Rather than comparing the price of a bag of logs with the price of a unit of gas, consider the cost of producing the same amount of useful heat.

For a meaningful comparison, look at:

  • The price of your chosen fuel.

  • The appliance's efficiency.

  • How much heat is delivered into the room.

  • How many hours you expect to use the fire.

  • Installation, servicing and maintenance costs.

Fuel prices change over time, so it's worth checking current prices before making your decision. A fire that is cheaper to buy may not necessarily be cheaper to run.

4. Which Is More Efficient?

Efficiency is another area where it's important to compare individual appliances rather than making assumptions based on fuel type alone.

Modern wood-burning stoves are designed to burn fuel more effectively than many older, traditional open fires. Gas fires also vary in efficiency, depending on their design and how they transfer heat into the room.

When comparing models, look at the manufacturer's stated efficiency and heat output. Consider how much heat you actually need and whether the appliance is suitable for the size of your room.

A correctly sized fire can make a real difference to comfort. An appliance that's too powerful for the space may leave you overheating the room, while one that's too small may struggle to provide the warmth you want.

It's also worth remembering that a stove or gas fire is not necessarily a whole-house heating solution. Its ability to heat other rooms depends on the property layout and how heat is distributed.

5. Which Is Better for the Environment?

Environmental impact is increasingly important when choosing a home heating appliance.

Wood and gas have different environmental considerations, and neither should be described as universally better in every respect.

Burning wood releases fine particles and other pollutants into the air. The amount produced depends on the appliance, the fuel, how the fire is operated and how well it is maintained. Even modern wood-burning stoves produce emissions, so choosing an appropriate appliance and burning suitable dry wood are important.

Gas combustion generally produces fewer local particulate emissions than burning wood in a domestic appliance. However, gas is a fossil fuel and releases carbon dioxide when burned. Its overall environmental impact also depends on fuel supply and the heating system being compared.

If reducing emissions is a priority, it's worth looking at the wider picture, including your home's insulation and other heating options. An electric fire may also be worth considering if you want the visual appeal of a flame without burning wood or gas in the room.

The best choice depends on your property, priorities and the way you intend to use the appliance.

6. Installation: What Does Your Home Need?

Before choosing between a wood-burning stove and a gas fire, consider the practical requirements of installing each appliance.

Installing a wood-burning stove

Your installer will need to assess the proposed stove location and establish a suitable flue arrangement. An existing chimney may need inspection, cleaning or lining, depending on its condition and the requirements of the appliance.

The hearth, ventilation, distances from combustible materials and other Building Regulations requirements must also be considered.

If your property doesn't have a traditional chimney, some wood-burning stoves can be installed using a suitable twin-wall flue system, subject to the property's layout and installation requirements.

Installing a gas fire

Gas fire installation requirements depend on the type of appliance and the existing fireplace or wall construction.

Some models use an existing chimney, while others require a suitable balanced flue through an external wall. The gas supply, ventilation requirements and clearances must all be assessed.

Every installation should be planned around the specific appliance and property rather than assuming that one arrangement will suit every home.

At Sussex Eco Solutions, we can help you understand the available options and the work that may be required before you commit to a new fire.

7. Wood Burner vs Gas Fire: Which Should You Choose?

The right choice comes down to what matters most to you.

A wood-burning stove may suit you if:

  • You love the atmosphere of a real log fire.

  • You enjoy the traditional look and feel of a stove.

  • You have suitable space to store logs.

  • You're happy to clean the stove and arrange regular maintenance.

  • Your property can accommodate a suitable installation and complies with local requirements.

A gas fire may suit you if:

  • You prefer heating at the touch of a button.

  • You want to avoid storing and handling logs.

  • You'd prefer less day-to-day cleaning.

  • You like the convenience of remote controls and adjustable settings.

  • Your property has, or can accommodate, a suitable gas supply and flue arrangement.

Both options offer a range of designs, so you don't necessarily have to compromise on appearance to get the practical features you want.

The important thing is to choose a fire that works for your home, your budget and your lifestyle.

8. Explore Fires and Fireplaces at Sussex Eco Solutions

Choosing between a wood-burning stove and a gas fire is much easier when you can see the options for yourself.

At Sussex Eco Solutions, we supply and install a range of fires and fireplaces, helping homeowners find an option that suits their property, preferred style and heating requirements.

Whether you're drawn to the character of a traditional log burner or the convenience of a modern gas fire, our team can help you explore the available choices and understand the installation considerations.

Visit our showroom in Littlehampton, West Sussex, to discuss your project and discover the possibilities for your home.

Ready to find your perfect fire?

Explore our wood-burning stoves, browse our gas fires or learn more about our fireplace installation services.

You can also call Sussex Eco Solutions on 01903 714381 to discuss your requirements.

The right fireplace should do more than keep you warm. It should make your house feel like home.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page